The Hexagon: An Exploration Tool
The Hexagon can be used as a planning tool to guide selection and evaluate potential programs and practice for use.
Usability - Rating: 4
4 - Usable
The intervention has operationalised principles and values, core components that are measurable and observable, tools and resources to measure fidelity, and identified modifiable components
Core Components
Mindfulness Based Cognitive Therapy (MBCT) is a group-delivered intervention that integrates theories and principles of Cognitive Behavioural Therapy (CBT) with Mindfulness Based Stress Reduction (MBSR) in order to address a range of psychological conditions (including generalised anxiety disorder and depression).
Mindfulness Based Cognitive Therapy (MBCT) is a standardised intervention that focuses on training in mindfulness approaches, with an emphasis on meta-cognitive awareness and learning to reduce reactivity to negative ruminations or emotions using the skill of “decentering” from negative thought patterns. This group-based intervention can be delivered to adults, adolescents and school-aged children to address a range of psychological and physical health conditions. MBCT is delivered over 8 weekly in-class sessions, each lasting between 1.5 to 2 hours. It can include a day-long meditation retreat and weekly homework practices to enhance learning. The sessions teach mindfulness practices that include mindfulness meditation on the breath, a body scan practice focusing on awareness of body sensations, mindful movement practice (based on gentle yoga or similar practices) and the application of mindful awareness in everyday life. This is integrated with a psychological model / framework which describes how common vulnerabilities and those specific to certain conditions are triggered and maintained with some curriculum elements drawn from CBT practice. The intervention aims to enhance awareness of present-moment experience, with increased acceptance and reduced reactivity / judgement. Individuals learn to step out of “automatic pilot” (where we are more likely to react unhelpfully to experience) and to inhabit more a state of “being” in awareness (where we have more choice in how we respond). This leads to reduction in rumination and worry, as well as enhancement in self-esteem, self-regulation, psychological resilience and life satisfaction.
Fidelity
Fidelity is enhanced through a range of competency criteria which includes observation / mentorship (through an apprenticeship model of training). Fidelity tools include the Mindfulness Based Intervention – ) (developed by Bangor Centre for Mindfulness) for observational feedback or self-reflection.
Training should follow an established / validated pathway meeting the Good Practice Guidelines established by BAMBA (British Association of Mindfulness Based Approaches). The NHS Education for Scotland Mindfulness Network has developed a local training pathway to meet the needs of NHS staff / services. It provides a listing of therapists who have completed the expected pathway and encourages an apprenticeship model where training and supervision is offered locally in Health Boards. The Scottish Mindfulness Network is a member of BAMBA and maintains links to this UK based charity to inform training, supervision and professional development of mindfulness therapists.
Modifiable Components
The MBCT protocol is typically applied to depressive disorders and can be modified to increase disorder specificity. For example, for anxiety disorders, the curriculum can include a cognitive–behavioural model for understanding the core features and maintenance of anxiety disorder, as well as sessions focusing on reactive–avoidance, ruminative worrying, and anxiety relapse prevention. In addition to face-to-face delivery. MBCT can be delivered on-line (using a secure platform). In addition, the curriculum can be covered using self-help resources (e.g. pre-recorded on-line programmes, apps, books, CDs and downloads). This may provide a useful adjunct to other forms of therapy. However, an 8-week face-to-face (or online) course is the “gold standard” in terms of effectiveness. MBCT is also available as Mindfulness Based Cognitive Therapy for Children (MBCT-C), a 12-week group intervention for children aged 8-12 years with anxiety.
Supports - Rating: 4
4 - Supported
Some resources are available to support implementation, including at least limited resources to support staff competency and organisational changes as a standard part of the intervention
Implementation Support
Implementation support can be provided primarily by the NHS Scotland Mindfulness Network (supported by NHS Education for Scotland). This is led by two coordinators (Neil Rothwell and Charlotte Procter) who oversee the Scotland wide network and Mindfulness Leads in each Health Board area (Scottish NHS Mindfulness Network, https://learn.nes.nhs.scot/40297/scottish-nhs-mindfulness-network, many of whom will be experienced at delivering training and supervision.
In addition, there are national organisations that guide the practice, teaching and development of mindfulness-based approaches and set standards around training and supervision. These include BAMBA (British Association of Mindfulness Based Approaches) and The Mindfulness network, who offer supervision, professional development and training. There are a number of additional training organisations (University, private or charity based) that can offer training, supervision and continuing professional development (many of which will be affiliated training organisations within BAMBA).
Implementation support for the delivery of on-line interventions should also include access to a suitable, secure platform which has been approved by the local Health Board. The platform should ideally have the option of break-out rooms.
Start-up Costs
Training in MBCT is provided at no cost if available through local NHS Health Board areas. This is dependent upon the availability of trainers (mindfulness therapists who have been trained to deliver a training) and their capacity to be made available to conduct training. Health Board areas may share resources / expertise to deliver training jointly. NHS staff will be able to complete the 8 week MBCT course at no cost if there are staff places available in patient focussed groups.
Costs will apply for training by private providers if there is no availability of local training within the NHS Boards and if a Health Board / service area is starting or restarting a mindfulness service.
Start-up costs include costs of basic training, optional membership of BAMBA (this is not a requirement of mindfulness therapists in Scotland as there is use of an alternative listing procedure), supervision fees. Additional costs apply including books / training materials / ongoing CPD events including mindfulness based retreats / intensive training.
- Staff attendance at an 8 week mindfulness based course (free if locally provided) or available at a number of locations (locally, on-line, staff based course run by NES) at a cost of between £200 - £300 (may be less if delivered on-line).
- Therapist training course (free if locally provided) or available through a variety of training organisations (University, private or charity organisations), usually in the form of a 12 month programme of training at costs ranging from £1, 350 - £1, 500 and University based courses ranging from £4000 to £5000. The courses differ in that some provide teacher training alone, some are competency assessed and others offer a Masters qualification.
- Supervision costs (free if offered locally with supervisors who have attended generic supervision training plus the additional training for mindfulness supervision) or privately at a variable cost (around £60 / hour). Expectation is for three half hour sessions of supervision (minimum for the delivery of a 8 week course) as a newly qualified therapist (over at least two 8 week courses) and ongoing monthly supervision (which can often be provided in a peer group setting).
- Fee for joining the BAMBA register of mindfulness therapists (optional for NHS Scotland therapists, but recommended if delivering privately), £90 for initial application and £37.50 for annual renewal.
- CPD costs (recommended two to seven days of annual training which may include CPD training days and intensive training in the form of practice “retreats”). £60 - £150 per day (costs vary). The NHS Scotland Mindfulness Network offers two CPD days per year (which are free to mindfulness therapists).
- Additional costs in the form of key texts / course books (around £25 - £100).
Building Staff Competency
Qualifications Required
MBCT is delivered in the NHS by professionals with a variety of backgrounds in health and social care (e.g. clinical psychology, psychiatry, occupational health, nursing, physiotherapy, OT, social work), who have professional training and experience in working with the population (in physical and mental health) to whom the intervention will be offered. MBCT draws upon cognitive theory, but is not cognitive behavioural therapy (CBT), and practitioners do not need to have pre-requisite training in CBT to deliver MBCT in an enhanced psychological practice framework.
Personal interest in mindfulness / meditation practice and a willingness to develop and sustain a personal practice is vital, as the intervention is delivered from the in-depth experience and embodiment of the practice. Those who already have a personal mindfulness practice (including a mindful movement practice such as yoga, T’ai Chi) will probably have a shorter training journey as they already have an established practice.
Training Requirements
Training comprises a 1-2 year journey starting with attending an 8 week mindfulness based course (MBCT /MBSR) as participant and to develop / sustain their own mindfulness practice over the course of around 12 months as a pre-requisite to therapist training.
The next step is to attend a therapist development course (4-7 training days along with an apprenticeship training in their local health board) or a 12-month MBCT Therapist Training course (delivered by a training organisation in the University, private or charity sector) which can be delivered face-to-face or remotely.
It is expected that trainees will deliver their first two courses under supervision / and as part of an apprenticeship model with a more experienced therapist prior to delivering courses independently.
There is no formal accreditation as part of the training courses, but local leads in Health Board areas will approve trainees as suitable for joining the NHS listing of therapists once they have completed training / apprenticeship and these will be listed on the NHS Mindfulness website.
Following training, therapists may choose to join the UK based register of mindfulness teachers with BAMBA who use a formal registration and re-registration process for an annual fee. This is not a formal requirement for professionals who are trained to deliver mindfulness interventions in NHS Scotland. Ongoing mindfulness practice and CPD is a requirement for the delivery of MBCT.
Supervision Requirements
It is recommended practice in Scotland that this psychological intervention is conducted under regular supervision with a practitioner who has expertise in MBCT / mindfulness based approaches, the clinical area in which it is being delivered and has completed training in supervision of psychological therapies and interventions (further information: https://www.nes.scot.nhs.uk/our-work/supervision-of-psychological-therapies-and-intervention/) including the Mindfulness Specialist Supervision Training component.
One to one supervision is particularly helpful for newly qualified therapists and MBCT group supervision is useful (as an alternative to ongoing one to one supervision) for more experienced MBCT therapists.
Evidence - Rating: 4 - 5
4 - Evidence
The intervention has demonstrated effectiveness with one rigorous, external research study with the focus population and a control group.
5 - High Evidence
The intervention has demonstrated evidence of effectiveness based on at least two rigorous, external research studies with the focus population and control groups, and has demonstrated sustained effects at least one year post treatment.
Theory of Change
MBCT aims to enhance metacognitive awareness by encouraging the adoption of “being mode”. In this mode, there is a non-judgmental present-centred awareness, and an interruption of the cycle of worry and rumination for past regrets and future fears. This is expected to disconnect the link between cognitive reactivity and escalating symptoms of mental health disorder.
Research Design & Number of Studies
Adult evidence depression
The evidence includes meta-analyses, some which focus on MBCT to treat current depression and some which focus on the role of MBCT in preventing relapse.
Goldberg et al (2019) meta-analysis included 13 RCTs and N = 1046 patients with current depressive symptoms. Included studies compared MBCT with therapeutic (active) controls or nonactive (non-specific) controls (2).
Sverre et al. (2023) conducted a meta-analysis of equivalence between MCBT and CBT using 30 RCTs with a total of 2750 participants (3).
Kuyken et al. (2016) which compared MBCT with usual care or at least one non-MBCT treatment for relapse prevention in recurrent depression. This review extracted individual patient data from previous studies and included 1258 patients (75% female) (4).
McCartney et al. (2021) performed a network meta-analysis with data from 14 RCTs including 2077 participants to assess the effectiveness of MBCT for relapse prevention and time to depressive relapse (5).
Zhang et al. (2022) meta-analysis included data from 7 RCTs with a total of 479 participants investigating the effectiveness of MBCT on suicidal ideation in patients with depression (6).
Reangsing et al. (2024) meta-analysis of 19 RCTs (N = 1480) to assess the effects of mindfulness-based interventions on pregnant women (717) vs controls (763) (7).
Generalised Anxiety - Adults - Rating: 4
Adult evidence - GAD or mixed anxiety disorders
The best available evidence demonstrating the effectiveness of MBCT in people with Generalised Anxiety Disorder (GAD) or mixed anxiety disorders includes two meta-analytic studies. The first meta-analysis included 6 studies that evaluated the effectiveness of MBCT in adults with GAD (8). The second meta-analysis included 3 studies that evaluated the effectiveness of MBCT in adults with GAD, PD or Social Anxiety Disorder (SAD) (9). The evidence below is limited to MBCT, and does not include other types of mindfulness-based interventions (e.g. mindfulness-based stress reduction).
Adult outcomes - GAD
- Significantly reduced anxiety symptoms at 2-months post randomisation (8)
- Significantly improved quality of life at 2-months post-randomisation (9)
Depression - Adults - Rating: 5
Adult outcomes - Depression:
- MBCT was superior in reducing depression to non-active controls or treatment as usual post treatment (2,5,6)
- Patients with a greater severity of depressive symptoms had a larger effect of MBCT compared with other treatments (4)
- MBT and CBT were statistically significantly equivalent at both post-intervention and follow-up (range 2-24months) (3)
- Patients receiving MBCT had a reduced risk of depressive relapse compared to non-active controls, but no statistically significant differences were observed between MBCT and active treatment strategies for rate of relapse or time to relapse of depression (5).
- Suicidal ideation scores were significantly improved following MBCT compared to TAU (6).
- In pregnant women, mindfulness-based interventions (MBIs) showed reduced depression compared to control groups. Subgroup analysis showed that MBCT had a greater effect on reducing depressive symptoms than MBSR and other adapted MBIs (7).
- Evidence for longer term efficacy is mixed with limited evidence for differences from other active therapies at 6mth follow up (2,4).
Chronic Pain - Adults - Rating: 4
Adult evidence – Chronic Pain
Some of the best available evidence for MBCT in chronic pain are summarised in meta-analytic reviews. These are described below, starting with the most recent. The reviews often involve a mix of Mindfulness-based interventions (e.g. MSR and MBCT). See also he MBSR intervention summary.
A meta-analytic study conducted to evaluate the effectiveness of mindfulness-based interventions on chronic pain outcomes reviewed 11 RCTs of mindfulness-based interventions that followed the standard MBSR or MBCT formats (10). Participants were those presenting with chronic pain including those with fibromyalgia, chronic musculoskeletal pain, rheumatoid arthritis, failed back surgery syndrome, or pain of mixed aetiology. Chronic pain was defined as persisting for ≥13 weeks. The mean age of participants ranged from 47–52 years, with the exception of the two studies conducted in older adults with mean age of 75 years.
Another meta-analytic review was conducted to determine the effectiveness of acceptance commitment therapy (ACT) and mindfulness-based interventions for the treatment of chronic pain (11). The main analytic review included 25 RCTs, of which 16 RCTs were mindfulness-based (including MBSR or/ and MBCT). Most mindfulness-based interventions were delivered in standard format, however one study delivered MBSR as a self-help intervention. The 1285 participants in the main analysis were adults, with a mean age between 35 and 60 years. Participants presented with different types of pain including musculoskeletal pain, fibromyalgia, specific-site pain (e.g. chronic low back pain, chronic headache), and rheumatoid arthritis. Subgroup analysis reporting the effectiveness of mindfulness-based interventions were reported separately from ACT at post-treatment.
A fourth meta-analytic review was conducted to determine the effectiveness of mindfulness-based interventions (including MBCT and MBSR) on somatization disorders (12). The meta-analysis included 13 RCTs that involved participants aged at least 18 years, presenting with fibromyalgia, chronic fatigue syndrome (CFS), irritable bowel syndrome (IBS), or non-specified/ mixed somatization disorder. Subgroup analysis comparing the types of mindfulness-based interventions (i.e. MBSR, MBCT, or non-specified mindfulness-based therapy) evaluated the primary outcome only (i.e. symptom severity).
Adult Outcomes for Chronic Pain
Compared to inactive controls, the following outcomes were reported;
Significantly reduced pain interference and pain intensity at post-intervention, sustained at 6-months follow-up
Significantly improved physical functioning (10,12,13) and quality of life (10,12) at post-treatment. Effects on physical functioning sustained at 6-months follow-up (13).
Significantly reduced depression symptoms at post-treatment (11-13) sustained at 6-months follow-up (13).
Significantly reduced symptom severity (including fibromyalgia, IBS) at post-treatment for MBSR and across other mindfulness-based interventions (12).
Significantly reduced pain outcomes (for IBS) at post-treatment (12).
Significantly reduced sleep disturbance at post-treatment, sustained at 6 months follow-up (13).
Need
Comparable Population
MBCT is delivered to adults, adolescents and school-aged children to address a range of psychological conditions, as well as physical conditions. Evidence of effectiveness has been demonstrated in people with recurring depression.
Desired Outcome
MBCT is associated with significant improvement across several outcomes including anxiety, depression, stress markers and quality of life. Some effects have been observed at 3 and 6 month follow-up.
1 - Does Not Meet Need
The intervention has not demonstrated meeting need for the identified population
2 - Minimally Meets Need
The intervention has demonstrated meeting need for the identified population through practice experience; data has not been analysed for specific subpopulations
3 - Somewhat Meets Need
The intervention has demonstrated meeting need for the identified population through less rigorous research design with a comparable population; data has not been analysed for specific subpopulations
4 - Meets Need
The intervention has demonstrated meeting need for the identified population through rigorous research with a comparable population; data has not been analysed for specific subpopulations
5 - Strongly Meets Need
The intervention has demonstrated meeting the need for the identified population through rigorous research with a comparable population; data demonstrates the intervention meets the need of specific subpopulations
Fit
Values
MBCT focuses on training in mindfulness meditation techniques, integrating some core features of Cognitive Behavioural Therapy (CBT) into Mindfulness Based Stress Reduction (MBSR) to address a range of psychological conditions. It aims to promote mindfulness via enhanced present-moment awareness and non-reactivity to enhance metacognitive awareness and reduce symptoms of mental health disorder.
Priorities
MBCT aims to reduce focus on past and future oriented ruminations and worry, and to enable the acknowledgement and acceptance of objective present experiences without reactivity or judgement. This helps to weaken the link between cognitive reactivity and escalating symptoms of mental health disorder. It can be delivered to adults, adolescents and school-aged children to address a range of psychological conditions (including depression and anxiety disorders).
Existing Initiatives
1 - Does Not Fit
The intervention does not fit with the priorities of the implementing site or local community values
2 - Minimal Fit
The intervention fits with some of the priorities of the implementing site, but it is unclear whether it aligns with local community values and other existing initiatives
3 - Somewhat Fit
The intervention fits with the priorities of the implementing site, but it is unclear whether it aligns with local community values and other existing initiatives
4 - Fit
The intervention fits with the priorities of the implementing site and local community values; however, the values of culturally and linguistically specific population have not been assessed for fit
5 - Strong Fit
The intervention fits with the priorities of the implementing site; local community values, including the values of culturally and linguistically specific populations; and other existing initiatives
Capacity
Workforce
MBCT can be delivered by professionals with backgrounds in health (physical and/ or mental), social care and education. Practitioners are required to attend an 8-week MBCT course, a 12-month MBCT therapist training course, and teach two supervised 8-week MBCT courses as well as maintain personal practice of mindfulness. MBCT is delivered over 8 weekly in-class sessions, each lasting about 2 hours, or can be delivered as an online course.
Technology Support
Practitioner therapist training and supervision can be accessed remotely. In addition to face-to-face delivery, MBCT training is available as an online program.
Administrative Support
MBCT is delivered over 8 weekly 2-hour sessions and can include an additional all-day session. It can be delivered in a number of settings (e.g. clinical, prisons, community settings). Administrative support will be needed for organising the course.
Financial Support
In Scotland, training is overseen by the Scottish NHS Mindfulness Network supported by NHS Education for Scotland. Therapist training and supervision can often be run within health boards by experienced trainers. The only cost for this is allocating time for the trainee therapists and supervisor / trainer(s). However, this training route currently has limited capacity.
External training is also available. The 8-week MBCT course costs around £200 per participant (may be less if an on-line course is attended) and the therapist training course costs between £1, 500 and £5, 000 (some courses are competency assessed and may offer a Master’s qualification; some consists of the training alone). Additional costs for MBCT resources and activities should be considered.
1 - No Capacity
The implementing site adopting this intervention does not have the capacity necessary, including a qualified workforce, financial supports, technology supports, and administrative supports required to implement and sustain the intervention with integrity
2 - Minimal Capacity
The implementing site adopting this intervention has minimal capacity necessary, including a qualified workforce, financial supports, technology supports, and administrative supports required to implement and sustain the intervention with integrity
3 - Some Capacity
The implementing site adopting this intervention has some of the capacity necessary, including a qualified workforce, financial supports, technology supports, and administrative supports required to implement and sustain the intervention with integrity
4 - Adequate Capacity
The implementing site adopting this intervention has most of the capacity necessary, including a qualified workforce, financial supports, technology supports, and administrative supports required to implement and sustain the intervention with integrity
5 - Strong Capacity
Implementing site adopting this intervention has a qualified workforce and all of the financial supports, technology supports, and administrative supports required to implement and sustain the intervention with integrity